Review: E’S, vols. 1-2

E’S, vols. 1 and 2
By Satol Yuiga
Rated 16+
Broccoli, $9.99

E’S is a stylish sci-fi manga along the lines of another Broccoli title, Kamui, but a lot more readable. By “sci-fi” I mean that it’s set in some post-apocalyptic future, but it deals more with emotion than technology. There are no flying robots or cities on trains; instead, E’S is an action story that folds in issues common to the genre such as the desire to rebel against a coercive society.

Warning: Spoilers and images after the cut.

The backbone of E’S is a set of manga conventions that are comfortably familiar. In a post-apocalyptic world, psychic teenagers are recruited by Ashurum, a shadowy, quasi-governmental organization, to (ostensibly) return order and rescue others like them. When one psychic, Kai, breaks free, he realizes the parent company may not be as benign as he thought. He is taken in by Yuuki, a mercenary with a heart of gold, who works for organized crime in the ruined city but also cares for orphans and strays. Completing the triumvirate of main characters is Yuuki’s ward Asuka, a girl who dresses in a bunny suit, is comically incompetent at everything, and can see directly into Kai’s soul. Have I left anything out? Oh, yeah they’re all supposed to be hunting for some terribly important object, the Sacrament of Calavarias, but so far, their efforts in that direction have been pretty desultory.

The book begins with Kai handily trapping a bad guy in a giant bubble of water while listening to music on his headphones. The first set of moral quandaries is set up in the next few pages, when Kai’s boss Eiji assures him that the captured man will be treated humanely—then issues the order to kill him as soon as Kai is out of sight.

Kai’s problem is that he is that he wants to live without violence in a world that is full of it. In this futuristic society, normal humans shun and persecute psychics, or at least that’s what he is told. Ashurum takes them in, treats them well, and trains them to go on exciting special missions (one of the really nice extras in vol. 2 is a recruitment brochure). They also cultivate the us-versus-them mentality. When Kai is sent as part of a group to wipe out a guerilla group in the city of Gald, he balks at carrying a gun. Always obliging, Eiji tells him he can carry an unloaded weapon. The result is, predictably, disastrous, and the incident ends with corpses scattered all over and an unconscious Kai being carted off to the land of bunnies and kittens.

Yes, that’s right, he ends up in Asuka’s greenhouse, where she cavorts in a bunny suit while thinking happy thoughts. Asuka might just be the most demented part of this manga, and she gets annoying at times, but she also keeps it interesting. Anyway, Kai has been injured, and without the drugs and conditioning he has been getting at Ashurum, his psychic powers are ebbing, although he still retains some abilities. Yuuki and a mysterious doctor also give him a dose of reality, explaining that Ashurum is not the benign, paternalistic organization he thought it was. Meanwhile, we get some glimpses of the inner workings of Ashurum and a look at their main man, the snappily dressed, utterly duplicitous Eiji. Eiji is one of the most interesting characters in the book; one moment he is being all cold-blooded-killer, and the next, he is reading bedtime stories to Kai’s little sister, who is seriously ill. (There’s another manga cliché for you: The hero who is motivated by his love for his vulnerable little sister. There’s a PhD thesis in that for someone.)

Of course the Ashurum folks are not happy that Kai is gone, and their efforts to get him back take up part of the second volume, but Yuiga throws in a little cross-dressing caper to lighten things up. And while E’S is laden with violence, there are occasional reminders that violence has consequences, and that the bodies being strewn across the splash panels are not just cardboard cutouts. So this is more than just a chase-and-fight story.

Yuiga’s drawing style is a notch above standard action manga. I particularly like the night scenes, in which we see the lit-up grid of the ruined city of Gald. The paneling is quite dynamic; Yuiga breaks an image into shards to emphasize action, scatters small panels across a panoramic scene, and deftly directs the eye through the page without confusion or obvious pointers. While the action gets very complicated in places, Yuiga often uses tones, simple shapes, and panels to keep the pages easy to read—as opposed, again, to Kamui, which I found harder to decipher. My biggest complaint is the standard manga problem: the characters look way too similar, although Yuiga does throw in a few variations in hair and costume.

E’S is a series that really benefits from Broccoli’s high production values. The covers of the first two volumes are attractive and point up the variety in the series. More importantly, the high-quality white paper holds the black ink well, allowing Yuiga’s art to really sing. The night scenes and the heavy action would have simply sunk in to standard manga paper and ended up as gray mush. And the volumes are packed with extras. The Broccoli editors like to start their volumes with a character guide, which is nice but a bit too much information if you read it first; I do like to be able to refer back to it, especially in books with similar-looking characters. Other extras include character notes, omake, and guides to Gald and Ashurum, which helped frame the story. My one quibble with these is the Broccoli tendency to use white type on a black page, which I find less readable than the reverse.

Like the best science fiction, E’S works as pure entertainment plus a little bit more. The art is a shade better, the characters a bit more thoughtful, than in your standard shoot-em-up. The one jarring note is the huge dollop of moe provided by Asuka and Kai’s little sister Hikaru. Those huge eyes, brimming with tears, are just… disturbing. Not disturbing enough to put me off the rest of the story, though. E’S is a keeper.

This review is based on complimentary copies supplied by the publisher.

Posted in Reviews | 4 Comments

Friday short stack

Shaenon Garrity’s latest Overlooked Manga Festival features Fumi Yoshinaga’s Flower of Life.

After almost three years, ADV Manga finally updated their website.

The Mainichi Daily News has a brief article on Comiket. (Via ComiPress.)

Translator Tomo Kimura points out a detail in Skip Beat!

Reviews: Floating Sakura reviews vol. 1 of My Heavenly Hockey Club at Manganews. Miranda checks out vol. 1 of Peacemaker and Ferdinand checks out vol. 1 of Dark Moon Diary at Prospero’s Manga. At Precocious Curmudgeon, David Welsh has some thoughts about vol. 17 of Fruits Basket (warning: spoilers!). Craig Johnson is disappointed by vol. 1 of Translucent at Manga Life. Nick enjoys vol. 1 of Air Gear at Hobotaku. At the Manga Maniac Cafe, Julie checks out vol. 1 of Togari. Adam Stephanides discusses a Japanese title, At the Mercy of the Waves, at Completely Futile. At Anime on DVD, Ariadne Roberts likes vol. 1 of Me and My Brothers, except for some translation/localization issues. Davey C. Jones checks out vol. 16 of Hunter x Hunter at Active Anime. And Chris Mautner checks out several new series for the Patriot-News.

Posted in Mangablog | 2 Comments

Charts-and-more

We have three manga earning spots on this week’s USA Today Top 150 best-sellers: vol. 17 of Fruits Basket debuts at number 99, vol. 20 of Bleach slips from 85 to 140, and vol. 14 of Fullmetal Alchemist checks in at 148.

Viz has five new shoujo titles lined up; ICv2 has the scoop. And the Naruto tsunami is on the horizon: Comicsnob says the next three volumes are already in the warehouses.

Tokyopop’s German arm has announced some new titles.

Bringing back a popular feature, The Otaku lists new releases for this week and last week.

Del Rey has relaunched their website

It’s the end of an era, albeit a short one: ChunHyang72 is ending her Tokyopop blog and will be focusing all her energies on Manga Recon (where she blogs under her real name, Katherine Dacey-Tsuei). The lack of RSS feeds has made it frustratingly difficult to keep up with the blogs on the Tokyopop site, so I’m a little late with this, but it’s worth noting as CH72 really helped provide an organizing principle in the early days of TokyoSpace. She offered pointers to the best of the content and guidelines for the inexperienced, and I think her influence made it a better place. Anyway, Tokyopop’s loss is PopCultureShock’s gain, and Katherine and co-blogger Erin F have made Manga Recon a lively and worthwhile read.

Site maintenance note: I updated the blogroll this morning to weed out the dead links. I also added two webcomics: My Poorly Drawn Life, Tania Del Rio’s very funny slice-of-life webcomic, which should have been in there ages ago (sorry Tania!), and Gal Samurai, a kogal-kicks-ass manga imported from Japan by Popteen.com (I reviewed it this week for Digital Strips). Enjoy!

Reviews: Julie checks out vol. 7 of Skip Beat! at the Manga Maniac Cafe. Leah enjoys vol. 1 of Black Sun, Silver Moon at Hobotaku. Eric P reviews vol. 2 of Kedamono Damono at Okazu. Kurishojo checks out vol. 7 of La Esperanca at Manganews. At Active Anime, Sandra Scholes reviews vol. 1 of Not So Bad. Leroy Douresseaux reviews vol. 1 of Heaven!! at The Comic Book Bin.

Posted in Mangablog | 6 Comments

Wednesday update

Congratulations to blogger extraordinaire Erica Friedman on the fifth anniversary of her blog, Okazu, and her 800th post, which coincide with a number of other milestones. As a latecomer to her blog, I was delighted by her explanation for the title.

It’s Wednesday, and David Welsh lists his picks from this week’s new comics at Precocious Curmudgeon.

Kai-Ming Cha reports on edu-manhwa at PWCW.

At the MangaCast, Ed has the latest news from DrMaster.

ComiPress reports that Pfizer has a web manga advertising Viagra up at its site. I posted a mini-review at Digital Strips.

At Comics Worth Reading, Johanna Draper Carlson is looking forward to some upcoming manga.

Comic Bits Online writes about manhua from Hong Kong.

Elae has some interesting news from Germany: A Subway to Sally anthology, in which various artists turn the band’s lyrics into comics.

Becky Cloonan posts some recent drawings at Ink and Thunder.

Viz is publishing the light novel Brave Story.

If you’re going to be in San Francisco tomorrow night, you should definitely check out Tezuka in the USA: A Manga Publisher’s Forum, which will bring together VIZ honcho Alvin Lu, Dark Horse uber-otaku Carl Gustav Horn, and Vertical’s witty Anne Ishii, and Ian Robertson of Viz Media to talk about publishing Tezuka in English and his influence on other manga.

Reviews: Jack Tse has an audio review of vol. 1 of Venus Versus Virus and vol. 1 of Samurai Commando at MangaCast. At Anime on DVD, Ariadne Roberts reviews vol. 1 of Hanami: International Love Story and the gang posts some Small-Bodied Manga Reviews. Matt Brady discovers there is life after Nana in his review of the September Shojo Beat. Michael Aronson reviews vol. 2 of Full Metal Panic and Dan Polley checks out vol. 1 of Alive: The Final Evolution at Manga Life. Greg McElhatton also critiques vol. 1 of Alive at Read About Comics. At Active Anime, Holly Ellingwood takes a look at vol. 8 of Skip Beat. Nick at Hobotaku enjoys vol. 1 of King of Thorn. Julie checks out vol. 9 of Black Cat at the Manga Maniac Cafe. At Prospero’s Manga, Miranda enjoys vol. 1 of I Hate You More Than Anyone and Ferdinand is “cautiously optimistic” about vol. 1 of Fantamir. Shaenon Garrity writes about vol. 1 of Astro Boy for the Tezuka: Marvel of Manga blog.

Posted in Mangablog | 7 Comments

Tuesday linkage

Comicsnob posts this week’s manga watch list.

Comics in the Classroom has an interesting interview with Jason Thompson about his upcoming Complete Guide to Manga.

Meanwhile, the Japan Times harrumphs that grownups these days are acting like a bunch of kids, with the the manga and the celebrities and all.

Baseball and bandits: Over at Same Hat! Same Hat!! Ryan and Evan present another comic you won’t see anywhere else: Yoshida Sensha’s The Young Bandit.

ICv2 has more on the three new titles announced by Yen Press at SDCC.

Reviews: In his latest Flipped column, David Welsh reviews vol. 1 of Alive and vol. 1 of Keys to the Kingdom. Craig Johnson reviews vol. 17 of Blade of the Immortal at Manga Life. At Okazu, Erica Friedman checks out vol. 1 of The Last Uniform and a Japanese light novel, vol. 3 of Strawberry Panic. Hobotaku gives a B- to vols. 1 and 2 of Midori Days, which seems generous to me. At the Manga Maniac Cafe, Julie reviews Hate to Love You. Connie checks out vol. 1 of Heroes Are Extinct at Slightly Biased Manga. Michelle Ramonetti looks at an older title, vol. 1 of Moon Child, at Anime on DVD. At Active Anime, Holly Ellingwood reads vol. 1 of Spell. Hung reviews vol. 4 of Stray Little Devil at the BasuGasuBakuhatsu Anime Blog. Over at Manganews, Cornerofmadness checks out vol. 2 of Kuro Gane.

Posted in Mangablog | 1 Comment

Monday roundup

The Weekly Recon is up, with a look at this week’s manga and brief reviews of recent titles from the always perceptive Katherine Dacey-Tsuei, at PopCultureShock.

David Welsh picks the gems from the latest Previews.

Should comics reviewers include art in their reviews? Chris Mautner asks around and gets opinions from a number of reviewers, including myself, at Blog@Newsarama. For the record, I don’t usually include art in my reviews but I have been thinking of starting, and this article has given me an extra nudge.

Otaku Champloo is looking forward to the new Japanese manga magazine, Jump Square.

Jason Thompson will be doing two panels at the Toronto Comic Arts Festival.

At the MangaCast, Ed has a side dish on Young Comic Magazine, which despite the name is aimed at mature readers.

Yuu Watase drew the cover for the September Shojo Beat, and inside the magazine she has a manga tutorial.

Same Hat! Same Hat!! reports on the consternation caused by manga-ka Kazuo Umezu’s red-and-white striped house.

One Potato Two writes about Koshihihikari rice, which pops up in a manga she is translating.

Reviews: Greg McElhatton reviews vol. 1 of Parasyte at Read About Comics. At the MangaCast, Readilbert writes about vol. 4 of Full House Kiss and Mangamaniac Julie reviews vol. 5 of ES: Eternal Sabbath. Hobotaku checks out vol. 1 of Black Metal. Manga Life catches up on their reading with reviews of vol. 1 of XS Hybrid by Craig Johnson, vol. 1 of Bleach by Michael Aronson, and vol. 1 of King of Cards by Dan Polley. At Comics-and-more, Dave Ferraro devotes Manga Monday to reviews of Apollo’s Song and vol. 9 of Monster. Matthew Alexander checks out vol. 1 of Venus Versus Virus at Anime on DVD. At the Manga Maniac Cafe, Julie reviews vol. 1 of Yume Kira Dream Shoppe and vol. 1 of Translucent. Leroy Douresseaux checks out vol. 1 of Monster at the Comic Book Bin. Manganews has some new reviews up: Lovers in the Night by Kurishojo, vol. 12 of The Wallflower by Floating Sakura, and vol. 2 of Blood Alone by Jiji.

Posted in Mangablog | 1 Comment