Wednesday quick links

It’s Wednesday, and MangaCast helpfully lists their recommendations for this week’s new manga. David Welsh lists his picks as well.

ComiPress translates an interview with manga-ka Naoki Urasawa in which he talks about drawing manga and his relationship with editors. David Welsh contrasts this with other recent interviews that touched on manga-ka and their editors.

Johanna gives her take on the Viz/Tokyopop question posed at Manga_Talk.

The RUSH anthology website is up. Critique at MangaCast.

Floating_Sakura answers some questions about the scanlation community and shares reactions to her last few posts.

Tokyopop editor Tim Beedle is posting lots of Blank art.

The Canandaigua Messenger-Post has a primer on graphic novels that includes the usual interviews with teens who read manga and librarians who say it draws in reluctant readers. Here’s a local comic-book dealer who doesn’t seem to get the concept:

The word “novel” in “graphic novel” is “misleading,” he asserted, because most are actually bound collections of four to eight 32-page comic serials and few feature original work created specifically for the “novel” format. It’s “like calling six episodes of a TV show a movie,” Churchill said. “Not that that’s necessarily a bad thing. It’s just more or less one of my semantic idiosyncrasies.”

While technically he’s right about licensed manga, I don’t think they usually read that way. And he’s dead wrong when it comes to other graphic novels. Meanwhile, the Herald-Mail includes O-Parts Hunter on its list of suggested gift books for teens.

This week’s Publisher’s Weekly Comics Week has an article on DC’s new Minx line and a review of O-Parts Hunter.

Awards watch: Horn Book editor Roger Sutton explains why it’s unlikely that a graphic novel will win a Newbery or a Caldecott award; the rules simply don’t envision such a creature. The Cybils do have a graphic novel category, and at MangaCast, Ed discusses the latest nominations.

You know that Roz Chast cartoon on manga? The one that John Jakala thought was xenophobic? At Completely Futile, Adam points out that the drawings are based on real manga and gives us a bit of background. ChunHyang72 offers her take on the cartoon and the New York Times piece on CLAMP.

At MangaCast, Ed reviews some manga for grown-ups: Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service, Golgo 13, and Masquerade Tokyopop blogger Andre posts about Urusei Yatsura, one of Rumiko Takahashi’s lesser-known titles.

Posted in Mangablog | 3 Comments

Manga in the news

The other media seem to be full of manga today. The New York Times has a feature article on CLAMP (registration may be required). Kethylia is not impressed, but Katherine Dacey-Tsuei adds a bit more. Meanwhile, John Jakala gets curmudgeonly about a Roz Chast cartoon about manga in this week’s New Yorker. (I have to say I agree with him, and I usually like Roz Chast.) And I believe this is a first: The manga version of Nancy Pelosi shows up in today’s Prickly City.

The AoD sleuths have been at it again and have dug up Amazon listings for several new titles that haven’t been announced yet, including one by Osamu Tezuka. Details and cover scans at MangaCast.

Meanwhile, Seven Seas does it the old-fashioned way and sends out a press release about their newest licenses, He Is My Master and Sota-Kun no Akihabara Funtouki (no English title yet). The first is a harem comedy starring a “14-year-old pervert” and a bevy of maids, while the other sounds like another fun-with-otaku title. Ed has covers and commentary at the MangaCast.

Paul Gravett has an article up about manwha artist Hyun Se Lee. (Via Journalista.)

ChunHyang72 rounds up what’s good at TokyoSpace, including this entry on the UK/Ireland Rising Starts of Manga finalists. Which begs the question: Isn’t that the sort of thing that Tokyopop should be promoting, perhaps by including it in the news section of the site? Because if not for this link, I’m not sure how people would find out about it. ChunHyang also has a pointed question for Tokyopop honcho Stu Levy: Where are all the bells and whistles we were promised?

Blog find: ReYa is a Swedish blog by two promising creators who have produced a very nice short manga, Butterfly Crush, that was published in Sweden. They also have links to their other work and some articles, although the articles are in Swedish. It’s a well designed site, so stop by and take a peek.

Creator Dan Hipp posts a preview of his upcoming Tokyopop title, Gyakushu!. (Via Blog@Newsarama.)

David Welsh has more on DC’s Minx imprint, comparing their plans with what’s already out there in manga form and commenting that stamping a name on something does not make it new.

ComiPress reports that a digitized version of Mitsuteru Yokoyama’s Romance of the Three Kingdoms Sangokushi will be released for the Nintendo DS in a hybrid form they’re calling a “gamic.” It will include sound effects and mini-games.

Play Magazine has a preview of the DrMaster title Purgatory Kabuki, according to MangaNews.

At MangaCast, Ed Chavez reviews Gakuen Heaven, Challengers, and Our Everlasting. Anime on DVD reviewer Patricia Beard looks at volume 1 of a new series from DMP, Rin! At ANN, Pata reviews Del Rey’s single-volume Train Man while Christopher Seaman at Active Anime has an advance review of volume 2 of the Viz version. Tangognat likes Blood Alone.

Posted in Mangablog | 5 Comments

Review: Kamui

Kamui, vols. 1–4
by Shingo Nanami
Rated 13+
Broccoli Books, $9.99 per volume

Warning: Spoilers after the cut!

Kamui is set in a dystopian future in which earthquakes have destroyed much of Japan and enormous monsters called Atanan roam the land. A quasi-military group of teenagers called NOA fights the Atanan, equipped with special powers. The catch—there is always a catch—is that they don’t understand where the powers come from. “Once you gain the power,” a commander named Sumire explains, “your sense of justice is paralyzed.” It’s a tradeoff she’s willing to make: “It’s better than being a weak human,” she says. “The world is falling apart. But as long as you have power, you can do something.”

Sumire is one of the three top officers of NOA. Together with the princely Shiki and the spectacularly evil Hyde, she is in charge of keeping the city secure, although the NOA officers seem to spend more time dallying with friends and spying on one another than actually fighting Atanan or plotting any strategy. (Shows what happens when you put teenagers in charge of civil defense.)

The action really begins with the arrival of Atsuma, a stranger from the north, who also possesses special powers. Infused with the spirit of an ancient sword, he has been sent by the elders of his village to recapture an ancient spirit, Okikurumi, which was stolen by someone in the research complex connected with NOA. His village is completely devoted to preserving Okikurumi, which somehow makes the rest of the world tick, and the theft threw the earth out of balance, triggering the earthquakes and the coming of the Atanan. Okikurumi is also the source of the NOA members’ powers, but only Atsuma seems to be aware of that.

That’s the backbone of the story, but there is much, much more. Nanami has put together an ensemble of varied characters, each with a distinct look, personality, and goal—not all of which is obvious at first glance. As the volumes progress, the story gets both clearer and more tangled, with secrets first hinted at and then revealed. Each of the first four volumes has a different feel. Volume 1 is all setup, and since the story is complicated, it’s tough going at times. Volume 2 is much more focused: A sympathetic young girl named Anzu is introduced, and the story of NOA and the earthquakes is retold through her eyes. Anzu is the classic strong-weak shoujo heroine, tardy and klutzy but good-hearted enough to get Atsuma’s attention through her sheer niceness. She and Atsuma start to become close, but then the dark forces on all sides reassert themselves in a violent outburst that wrecks NOA and puts her in the hospital. Volume 3 returns to the main characters as they each resume their quests in the now-destroyed NOA headquarters. This volume also introduces Utsuho, the mastermind behind NOA. And volume 4 is mostly backstory, set in the remote village that was Okikurumi’s home, showing how Utusuho and Atsuma came to be where they are. This story starts out like folklore but quickly turns disturbing, as the villagers’ beliefs push them to unthinkable cruelty to preserve Okikurumi—only to have Utsuho snatch it away from them.

Nanami’s art is crisp and very linear, with lots of flowing lines and sharp edges. The characters are drawn in an almost stereotypical manga style, with big eyes, pointy chins, and elongated bodies, but each one has a distinct look that telegraphs his or her personality: the languid Sumire, the mischievous Shui, the scheming Yanagi. The art can be overly busy at times: Even relatively static scenes are filled with swirling hair, flowing cloaks, and other complications, and the fighting scenes are so filled with speed lines that the main action is sometimes hard to see. Sound effects are retained and translated, which heightens the sense of action but also adds to the visual clutter. On the other hand, when she focuses on individuals, as in the story of Anzu, Nanami’s style is simpler and quite lovely.

Broccoli has some of the best production values in the business, and these books are no exception. The trim size is slightly smaller than most manga, but the paper is the best I’ve seen, bright white and fairly heavy. The books feel stiff but loosen up a bit as you read. The covers each feature a different character and the colors are lovely. Extras include a color page in the front, an illustrated list of characters (very handy for a book this complicated), translator’s notes, a glossary, and two pages of “after talk” from the creator. Each volume also includes a preview from the next book, but I deliberately skipped those.

Kamui takes a while to warm up to, but the characters are interesting and the plot is compelling. Besides a good story, it also offers one of the satisfactions of good science fiction, contemplation of the human condition and the choices we make to survive. With volume 5 just appearing on the shelves, this is a good series to pick up now.

(This review is based on complimentary copies provided by the publisher.)

Posted in Reviews | 2 Comments

Falling down the manga hole

We got a little surprise in the funnies today: Prickly City, a conservative-slanted newspaper strip with a wry sense of humor, has gone manga for the week. The reason: Cartoonist Scott Stantis is recovering from shoulder surgery, so artist Sarah White is filling in. You can see more of her work at her Deviant Art page.

Nominations are up for the Cybils, the Children’s and YA Bloggers’ Literary Awards, and there are a number of manga on the graphic novels list.

The Manga_Talk group has been busy lately. Draconianangel is asking whether readers prefer Viz or Tokyopop. A lively discussion ensues in the comments, and it seems like Viz wins out but nobody is super-enthusiastic about either one. Meanwhile, Homasse asks about translating the untranslatable, and again, the commenters come through. And Kate_nepveu posts detailed commentary on the art of Saiyuki.

Colleen Doran clears out her closets and finds some cool old drawings.

News briefs from ComiPress: 20th Century Boys is back and manga-ka Taira Hara has died.

Alan Payne, National Accounts Manager at Tokyopop, is leaving to become VP of sales at IDW.

David Welsh overhears a perplexed parent trying to buy manga.

This will help you whittle down the stack: an automatic manga reader. (Via ComiPress.)

The Ann Arbor News has a guide to Japanese culture in Michigan, “from Ypsilanti to Chelsea.”

At the Star of Malaysia, Kurogane reviews Viz’s Densha Otoko.

Posted in Mangablog | 5 Comments

Make mine Minx

It’s not manga, but it could be serious competition: Everyone was abuzz this weekend with the news that DC is starting a line of graphic novels aimed at girls. Even the New York Times picked up on it (link may expire soon). Johanna articulates the two biggest criticisms of this line: All but one of the creators are men (although the two editors are women) and DC may not be the best company to do this, given their track record and the misogyny of some of their other products:

It’s very odd to see a company whose core line of comics is so unfriendly and hateful towards women launch this effort. Something of a mixed message there, or is this intended to assuage critics? “Oh, don’t worry about the rape and murder in our superhero books — the comics for you girls are over there.”

Christopher Butcher points out that the whole thing is a bit redundant because the girls already have manga. I’m not sure that’s a legitimate criticism, as there is always a group who will turn up their nose at manga, and I can understand DC wanting to broaden their market. However, I think Chris is right that DC didn’t do a good job of initially marketing CMX.

[The NY Times article] mentions that the new Minx line will be launched with actual money and a Marketting firm, unlike CMX, where “The marketing then was similar to that used for DC’s other titles.” Heh. More and more, CMX just feels like it was sabotaged on purpose, doesn’t it?

Also, he highlights one fact that hasn’t gotten a lot of attention: DC is turning over marketing to Alloy Marketing + Media. The NY Times notes that another Alloy division, Alloy Entertainment, was the book packager responsible for the “Opal Mehta” plagiarism case. To give them their due, they are also responsible for two highly successful franchises, the Gossip Girls and the Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants, and it looks like DC is using them strictly for marketing, not as a packager. Still, it seems like a departure for any comics company to do mass marketing.

On her LJ, creator Rachel Nabors picks up on the point about the creators being men:

Scholastic’s Graphix line featured tried and true female creators who already had proven their abilities to write to girls. So why did DC choose male talent when there are still so many talented women in the industry ready to work? Why all the boys?

In the comments, Warren Ellis snarkily responds

Oh, they did that specifically to annoy you, and in revenge for Joanne Rowling writing the most successful boy’s-adventure YA novels of the last 50 years.

Actually, at this thread on The Engine, Shaenon Garrity says

And I know that [Minx editor] Shelly Bond went out of her way to try to recruit more female creators, because I was one of them (my pitch sucked, sadly; I’m not very good at writing for teens).

Andi Watson, the author of one of the Minx titles, agrees:

That’s what I understand. Some creators weren’t interested and then I guess other pitches were rejected (a bunch of mine went in the bin too).

And Johann Chua says don’t discount the editors:

For some strange reason most shoujo manga editors are still men. The Magnificent Forty-Niners who established manga for girls being created by women had them. Hell, all the ground-breaking shounen-ai titles of the seventies had them as well.

In fact, many commenters at The Engine and Comics Worth Reading thought the two women editors were the high point of the Minx line.

I am fortunate to have a member of Minx’s core demographic living with me: My 13-year-old daughter, who is a voracious reader of both manga and YA novels. I asked her if she reads any books by men. “The one I’m reading right now is by a guy,” she said. That would be Neil Gaiman’s Stardust. I would have guessed otherwise, because in the past she has read a lot of girl-oriented fiction such as The Clique novels by Lisi Harrison and the novels of Louise Rennison, which seem to be entirely concerned with embarrasing dating mishaps, but now she’s dismissing these as “immature.” Still, somehow I doubt that a guy could write as convincingly as Rennison about a cat eating your false eyelashes or about doing the “lets go down to the disco” dance with your girlfriends. Just sayin’.

Posted in Mangablog | 1 Comment

Another day, another podcast

MangaBlogCast #19 is up at the MangaCast, and this one is short and sweet, because we put it together just before the holiday. Here are the links for further reading:

Creators and reviewers

Review of Mail Order Ninja at Comics Worth Reading
Elder complains at The Engine
Elder’s reply to criticism of his comments
Newsarama Blog coverage, including Elder’s offer of free copies of Mail Order Ninja to anyone who will review it
Elder becomes reviewer for Sun-Times

The three-act manga

Christopher Butcher’s review of Fool’s Gold
Queenie Chan on the three-volume format
Butcher’s reply
Heidi’s comeback

Johanna Draper Carlson interviews manga adapter Kelly Sue Deconnick for PWCW

Direct market: Hardbacks drown manga

Direct market sales charts from ICv2
Hardcovers drive graphic novels sales
Comments by David Welsh

Listmania

Amazon’s Best of 2006: Comics and Graphic Novels
Publisher’s Weekly’s Best Books of the Year – Graphic Novels

Floating Sakura discusses the state of the scanlation community

Tezuka Down Under

Tezuka manga plastered on Minis
Curator Brophy on Tezuka
Really good article on Tezuka in The Australian

Incoming…

Fullmetal Alchemist, vol. 10
xxxHOLiC, vol. 8
Hayate the Combat Butler, vol. 1
R.O.D: Read or Dream, vol. 1
ES: Eternal Sabbath, vol. 3
Gals!, vol. 8

Posted in Mangablog | 2 Comments