ANTARA News brings tidings of British kids reading these strange comics called “manga.” How quaint. Oh, wait a minute:
Data provided by Nielsen BookScan shows sales of graphic novels and manga have shot up from just over 100,000 units ($2.8 million) in 2001 to nearly 600,000 units ($10.3 million) in 2005.
There’s not a lot new here, but I’m going to take issue with this:
By publishing “Buddha,” Harper Collins is hoping to give manga more literary acclaim and change the misconception that manga is only for children. At the moment, the vast majority of readers in Britain are children and teenagers. It is hoped though that in the future these young readers will continue their habit and look for more complex stories.
I would submit that Buddha is exactly the wrong book to carry that message. It will establish that manga is not for children, true. But I’m not sure how adults in a brand-new market will react to its peculiar combination of Astro Boy-like figures with graphic violence and nudity. It’s a classic, but it’s also dated and not particularly representative of modern manga. I would rather see them bring over a modern adult comic like Death Note, Nana, or Monster. I also think that josei manga might appeal to the women who grew up reading Bunty and Diana and Jackie, which were comics for girls and teens that had stories similar to those in manga. But Buddha? No. Save that for the advanced class.